The AAMC listing
has so many inconsistencies with the mjor one being that it is basically
a Bruggmann listing. Indeed he is the father of Philippine aerophilately
but he is not Philippine aerophilately. His listing, if I may be blunt
about it, is self-serving. Not a catalog but a seller's list only.
You could say
that this is a fine tuned AAMC list. The assignment of catalog numbers
is consistent Series flights like the 1927 flights to the Southern Islands
arranged to what I think is the right sequence based on dispatch dates
and arrival postmarks. I purposely left out catalog values. I believe that
proper valuation can be best achieved by a panel of collectors and not
by one individual. The list is also not based on the Chiong collection
alone. For the past twenty years I have kept tabs on flight covers
even though I never collected them. In fact they are the only collector
prepared items that like.
I am giving
birth to the initials "FNC" which is for FOOTNOTE COVERS. These are flight
covers worthy of note but I personally do not think they merit catalog
numbers. The first FNC in my list is AAMC 1Ab. It does not make sense
to assign a catalog number to a flight cover with "NONE KNOWN TO EXIST."
In my listing
the AAMC numbers out of the window. Likewise I assigned numbers to covers
flown from Point A to Point B. Covers that were in part coursed by surface
either from point of origin or to point of destination are documented as
FNC. So the 1926 Aparri to Manila of the Madrid-Manila flight is no longer
number 11 in my list. I know that this will be frowned upon by many. There
will be an uproar. Disturbing a recall is just like stepping on a ant hill.
In time you will be calmed, you will adjust, you will hopefully accept
and adopt. My intent is pure patriotic. Philippine numbers for Philippine
flights. It makes sense! Linda Stanfield produced a catalog on Republic
flights with "RP" prefix. As her student my numbering with the "PI" prefix.
The AAMC unrecorded or unlisted flights in my list validated to have been
flown be they be in the name of Bruggmann or not.
Thank you.
aql |